Showing posts with label Business Rates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Business Rates. Show all posts

Monday, 24 February 2014

Carbonised Cookware...



The hospitality industry, and the pub sector in particular, is populated by "big personalities", none less than Tim Martin, founder and CEO of the ubiquitous JD Wetherspoon (JDW) chain of managed pubs. So when these captains of industry speak out their words are taken note of and afforded a level of respect concomitant with their standing. But we should be cautious about accepting all their promulgations without applying a critical eye. In the latest edition of the JDW "Wetherspoon News" Mr Martin attempts to analyse why so many pubs have closed their doors for the last time in the past decade.


“Who killed Cock Robin? I, said the sparrow, with my bow and arrow, I killed Cock Robin…” Unlike the sparrow, no one has stepped forward to accept blame for the killing of 10,000 pubs which have shut down in the last ten years – about 15% of the total number of pubs in the country. A large amount of blame can be attributed to the VAT inequality between pubs and supermarkets. Supermarkets pay no VAT on food sales, whereas pubs pay 20%, allowing supermarkets to subsidise their drinks prices with their massive ‘tax break’. Another huge factor relates to the business rates disparity between pubs and supermarkets. The average pub pays around 6% of its sales as rates. This amounts to about 15p a pint, believe it or not. Supermarket chain Morrisons’ chief executive, Dalton Philips, told the Financial Times (11 July 2013) that his company paid £240 million of business rates in the previous year. Morrisons’ accounts for the year in question (to February 2013) show sales of £18.116 billion. Supermarkets, therefore, appear to be paying rates somewhere in the region of 1.32% of their sales. So, a pint purchased in a supermarket for about £1.25 will have a business rates cost of roughly 1.65p. This analysis clearly demonstrates that each pint purchased in a pub has approximately nine times the level of business rates as a pint purchased in a supermarket. You don’t have to be Mark Carney, governor of the Bank of England, George Osborne or Ed Balls to work out the economic consequences of the disparity in VAT and rates between pubs and supermarkets."
Can't fault you there Tim, VAT and Business rates in their current incarnations undoubtedly disadvantage pubs compared to other retail businesses, for despite all the mythology surrounding our national watering holes, they are just that, retail businesses, it's just their stock in trade is food and alcohol and not other commodities. Jacques Borel has been campaigning, to mixed success, throughout the EU to bring VAT rates down for the hospitality industry citing the advantages of increased tax revenues, more employment and enhanced inward investment as the benefits to national exchequers. Unfortunately it seems the current occupant of No. 11 Downing Street has firmly set his face, and his administration's, against this much needed tonic for the British economy and hospitality industry, despite hard evidence from countries which have adopted this progressive tax regime. Perhaps it was too much to think reducing beer duty by a penny a pint and scrapping the beer duty escalator last year was a herald for a more sympathetic (one could say enlightened) approach to taxation for our benighted industry.


"However, there are a lot of other tax disparities in addition – for example, the coalition government increased taxes on fruit machines and introduced a ‘late-night levy’, taxes which apply only to pubs, further increasing their economic disadvantage. I doubt that the government or the treasury has malicious intentions towards pubs, but I strongly suspect that they haven’t thought through the financial consequences of their actions, a malaise which also afflicted the previous Labour government. No thoughtful or sensible economist, presented with this information, would deny the huge impact of the tax system on pub closures."
Again, not a lot to argue with there, when as I write we still endure the second highest level of alcohol duty in the EU.


"However, the situation is complex and there are indeed other factors, less important overall, which have contributed to the demise of so many pubs. The main additional reason for pub distress is the high level of debt assumed by some pub companies in the years running up to the credit crunch. Two of the main architects of the debt-fuelled pub boom were Guy Hands, formerly of Japanese bank Nomura, and Hugh Osmond, a financier who has been involved in substantial debt-raising exercises in respect of public companies. In essence, Hands and Osmond bought the large tenanted pub estates of the major brewers, using borrowed money, and then hiked up the rents and the beer prices paid by the tenants. As a result of the increased income which they generated, they were able, in effect, to remortgage the pubs, extracting tens of millions of pounds of ‘profit’ for themselves. The problem, in my opinion, is that the so-called ‘business model’ which they helped to pioneer was unsustainable – and thousands of tenants have gone to the wall – and thousands of pubs have closed. Not all pub closures were formerly tenancies, but very many were. After Hands, Osmond and their acolytes and imitators sold out, the majority of the pubs in the tenanted estates ended up with public companies called Enterprise Inns and Punch Taverns. They continued to buy pubs and increase debt (as well as continuing to increase rents and beer prices for tenants) right up until the credit crunch hit. When the individual licensees/tenants started to suffer between the hammer of high rents and beer prices and the anvil of the tax-subsidised supermarkets, unprecedented numbers of publicans went bankrupt – and the Enterprise and Punch shares plummeted on the stock market to a fraction of their former value."
Bang on the money, but let's not forget the infamous Giles Thorley who trousered a reported £35 millions from his time at the helm of the now sinking Punch Taverns.


"A depressing aspect of this sad chain of events has been the attitude of the former pub Titans to the plight of the tenants. Guy Hands and Hugh Osmond, joined recently by former Enterprise Inns’ boss Ted Tuppen, have said nothing at all about the tax disparity with supermarkets which weighs even more heavily on pubs than their own financial engineering. Yet they have been exceptionally vociferous in criticising high tax rates which apply to them personally. Guy Hands, in high dudgeon, removed himself some time ago to the tax haven of Jersey. Hugh Osmond and Ted Tuppen remain residents, but have been shouting from the rooftops at the injustice of the Labour Party’s proposal to increase the top rate from 45 to 50%. There is a justifiable argument for a reasonable top rate of tax which encourages hard work – Britain did not benefit from the Rolling Stones hiding from the taxman in the south of France in the 1970s. However, the disregard of the financial engineers for the plight of their tenants and their egocentric concentration on their own positions, dressed up as national concern, might even have caused Maggie Thatcher to side with Ed Balls.

 How true Tim, although I doubt the late (not)lamented Baroness would go as far as that, let's face it, it was under her administration the ill-conceived Beer Orders came into force, which paved the way for the likes of Hands, Osmond, Thorley, Tuppen et al (the agents and brokers of one of the biggest property bubbles in British business history).

What Tim neglects to mention are the societal changes, engineered by government, which have occurred over the last decade too, for instance the introduction of the ban on smoking in public places in 2007 which in spite of the health lobby's assurances that pubs would fill with non-smokers who had previously eschewed our smoke-filled pubs, must have been a significant factor in the closure of many "land-locked" pubs which simply couldn't provide outside facilities for smokers. And I would wager, there isn't a pub in the land which permitted smoking prior to the ban that hasn't seen a drop off in trade as smokers remain in the comfort of their own homes drinking cheap supermarket tinnies.

Tim also neglects to mention, not surprisingly, his own company's part has to play in the demise of many independent pub businesses throughout the land. Whilst one tries not to be a "poppy reaper" and lambast the entrepreneurial skill of self-made tycoons, it is somewhat disingenuous of Mr Martin to omit his own creation's contribution to the decline of the national pub estate. For, every time a new "Spoons" is announced independent pub landlords in the vicinity must shudder as the prospect of the lowest common denominator comes crashing into their local micro-markets. Many a publican will be able to tell you of the devastating effect a new JDW site has on their business as the "pile it high, sell it cheap" business model adopted by Tim Martin is the economic equivalent of a sink hole opening in the middle of their neighbourhood. 

Note to self, go to my local independent pub tonight (not usual on a Monday) and have a pint, for if we all did that even just once a week instead of drinking in managed chains (or quaffing on the sofa) we might help reverse the seemingly inexorable decline of the pub trade in this country.

Friday, 15 February 2013

Coming to a high street soon?



With news in from the Independent that less than 10% of the £1.2million set aside by government for the Portas project to bring some of Britain's high streets back to life and the never ending revelations about tax dodging by big businesses across the board I've come up with a way to do what Portas wants (stop the deracination of our town centres) and the rest of us want (for all taxpayers, whether corporate of personal to pay their fair share of tax) ... it's relatively simple ... a business rate surcharge directly linked to the proportion of on-line sales for retailers and service providers.

It would work in a similar way to the highly discriminatory method currently used to determine the way pubs are rated by Fair Maintainable Trade and notional market rents (determined by the pubcos etc in cahoots with the Valuation Office) ... and its called The Community Retailing Quotient (CRQ).

CRQ is a surcharge on business rates valuations linked to the proportion of turnover a retailer derives from online sales emanating from their premises. The CRQ system would give relief from the surcharge to the same value as each local authority's median business rates valuation, at which point the surcharge as a percentage of trade which is attributed to online sales for any transaction originating in the UK for the business operator is levied on top of their standard business rates valuation. (By the way this would also work for all the utility companies etc who avoid their tax obligations and have spent a decade or more persuading us all to go online to order and pay for their services.)

As there are regional variations in the density of premises used by online retailers etc, funds collected from the CRQ would be remitted by local authorities to central government to offset the budget cut requirements of the Treasury enforced on local authorities. Broadly cost neutral for the exchequer, less minimal administration costs, plus savings for HMRC from not having to pursue global companies for their fair share of other taxes, such as VAT and corporation tax.

Of course, there are businesses that already contribute to their local economies by having high street premises and also retail online; those specific premises would be exempt from the CRQ surcharge as they are already "fair retailers".

Use of business premises by online retailers as local collection points for customer orders located in town/city centre retail areas could be offered an introductory business rates holiday, say, the first six months, equivalent to each local authority's median business rates valuation and exemption from the CRQ for those premises. Online retailers locating to city/town retail areas would have sufficient operating costs saving to promote their new community based business, say, from reduced distribution centre to household courier fees, this transportation cost being transferred to the consumer.

Having a "utilities hub" in each town centre where consumers could interact with real people when they need advice about tariffs, energy efficiency etc could be another way for some big businesses to mitigate its CRQ liability. Surely some of us can remember Gas Board, Water Board, Electricity Board, and BT shops where one could make payment, get advice etc? We could even have banks with real bank managers, not customer service representatives ... wouldn't that be novel!


By returning footfall to high streets online retailers/service providers can continue to trade online and pay a fair share of taxation and encourage customers to join them in their collection outlets ... needless to say these outlets, if presented as glorified Argos stores, wouldn't be popular with significant numbers of consumers ... so collection outlets could incorporate cafes, bars and casual dining operations, no doubt equipped with free wi-fi or hard-wired sales terminals to order whilst in-store. Can you imagine the achingly hip and cool new incarnations of shops if Google and Ebay offices are anything to go by?

(Not to interrupt the flow of your reading but this just published in Marketing Week about Google's plans for retail outlets 19/2/13)

Local communities benefit from the renaissance of our high streets, essential local services could be protected; jobs could be created where they are needed, in local communities, (albeit at the cost of more "cloning") and online retailers/service providers gain an additional income stream and renewed customer confidence and trust in their brands.

Of course, this will never happen, as while it would be broadly cost neutral for the Treasury, it would cost big business billions in increased tax and other costs ... and their owners/shareholders, bankers, accountants, lobbyists and our political "representatives" will never stand for that. Even if they did acquiesce there would still be a bar to this being adopted ... us.

We just love not having to stir our stumps and prefer all the things we consume to be delivered to our doors, be they real world or digital.

Tuesday, 5 February 2013

Pubs ... everybody's whipping boy ...


The Government “will shortly consult” on regulations for locally-set licensing fees with introduction expected in the summer, the Home Office has confirmed, as reported in the Publicans' Morning Advertiser today



Councillor Mehboob Khan, chair of the LGA’s Safer and Stronger Communities Board, said: 

“It’s clearly wrong that taxpayers are subsidising the drinks industry. Councils want to support good local pubs but cannot be expected to continue picking up the tab for licensing fees which are outdated and not fit for purpose."

“As well as meaning more taxpayers’ money could be spent on frontline services, a more flexible licensing system would help councils support responsible venues which enrich local communities and put pressure on those which encourage excess drinking, noise and high street mess."







Why is it always pubs, probably the most responsible and controlled environments for the consumption of alcohol pilloried by all and sundry? Where is his opprobrium for the off-trade, such as the big supermarkets, who flood the market with cheap booze and don't supervise its consumption? Take a stroll down most high streets and look at the mess that other premises licensed under the Licensing Act cause ... and I'll venture that pubs cause less mess than that generated by the plethora of late-night take-away premises ... it's certainly the case in my neighbourhood.

Here's a little more analysis:

166,000 licensed premises in UK, deficit over 6 years is £100millions so a one-off charge for the "under-payment" of costs per premises of £612. Then £102 extra per year for the next 5 years, review the situation and set new fees.

The quid pro quo? Business rate reform so that pubs are valued and rated in the same way as other retail businesses ... I know which most pubs would prefer.

Simplistic? Yes it is, but no more simplistic than the comments by Councillor Khan ... why are they limited to pubs, what about off-trade? What about the food and other premises covered by the Licensing Act? As others have pointed out what about a review of other fees local authorities have the right to impose?

It's fair enough to put right the mistake of the previous administration by setting fees too low ... or were they? Have councils just been incredibly inefficient in processing licensing applications etc? Allowing local authorities to set their own fees will reward those that are financially inefficient ... so yet another consultation process for the mandarins and politicians ... wonder how much the consultative process costs the country every year as well?

 

Front-Line Services?


And before I sign off on this topic ... Kirklees Council (Councillor Kahn is their leader, I believe) must be a bit strapped for cash, what with spending £25,000 making sure its 69 councillors all got equipped with i-Pads just in time for Christmas 2012 ... it's a shame that pubs will be targeted to pay for this kind of profligacy. I wonder are i-Pads for councillors part of a council's front-line service provision in the ivory-towers of Kirklees?

By the way, an ipad 2 cost £329 from the Apple Store, which, is probably the most expensive way to buy them ... so with an entire Local Authority's purchasing power at its disposal why did Kirklees pay £362 a piece? Could this be a portent of the efficient way that it and other members of the LGA will administer licensing?

Nurse! Meds! Now!

Saturday, 26 May 2012

Plan A ... Kaput, Plan B ... Just a Rapper, So Georgie ... Plan C?

You'd think that even the posh-boys in No 10 and No 11 couldn't be that deaf to the increasing chorus of national / international opinion that they should do something to stimulate growth in the UK economy ( Obama, IMF, IPRR, CBI, TUC, IOD ... the list goes on and on) ... but then again no.

Here's a totally pub-centric set of proposals:


1) Drop VAT to 5% for the hospitality industry

2) Scrap the Beer Duty Escalator

3) Forget Minimum Pricing

4) Regulate the Pubcos

5) Equalise Business Rates for pubs in line with other businesses





How the five point plan would help pubs ... and what you can do to help achieve these aims:

Jacques Borel, from the VAT Club reckons that a drop in VAT would create over 300,000 jobs (if you want a copy of the fact pack email: adam.pescod@wrbm.com) if you haven't signed the e-petition then do so now - click here

Scapping the Beer Duty Escalator would go a long way to protecting what the British Beer and Pub Association estimates are the 400,000+ jobs that rely on beer and its sale - if you haven't signed the e-petition then do so now - click here

Minimum Pricing won't solve the problem of alcohol abuse and will only further burden those on low incomes who enjoy alcohol "responsibly". If you haven't signed the e-petition then click here

Regulating the Pubcos to ensure that there is an equitable division of profit so that tenants can earn a living and invest in their businesses will help to further slow the demise of the Great British Pub - if you haven't contacted your MP regarding this matter then click here

Treat all tax payers equally as the HMRC mission statement says and stop the nonsense of rateable values for pubs being based on mythical market rents, fair maintainable trade and turnover. Challenge the Valuation Office at every opportunity ... way too many business rates petitions to choose from!

Pubs (and the brewing and hospitality industry in general) are huge wealth creators, employment providers and more importantly part of the social "glue" that keeps this country together ... on average a community pub contributes over £80,000 a year to its local economy according to the IPPR

To paraphrase JFK ... "ask not what your pubs can do for you ... but what you can do for your pubs ..." something we should be telling all our customers. Get them involved even if it's just based upon ruthless self-interest ... for them and you!

Saturday, 31 March 2012

From Each According To Their Means ...

Marxism may truly be out of fashion but the loose translation of Marx's 
  "Jeder nach seinen Fähigkeiten, jedem nach seinen Bedürfnissen!" 
by old school Socialists as "from each according to their means, to each according to their needs" has always seemed a reasonable enough approach to social and economic responsibility in a 'modern, civilised' society. 

The "Tesco Tax" being introduced in Northern Ireland this weekend is a bold statement by its community  leaders that large businesses including retailers such as Tesco should start paying a little more to the communities they 'serve'. In light of the Portas Review of Britain's high streets and the effect that large out of town retail developments have had on town centres it's only right that the balance is redressed to help small businesses by redistributing the burden of business rates from those least able to pay to those most able to pay. And oh what joy that it's to be introduced on April 1st!

Whilst this is a welcome move for some small businesses more needs to be done to redress the balance between other sectors of the high street and the disparity in business rates- the iniquitous way that pubs are treated compared to other retail businesses. 
 
The Valuation Office uses a combination of Fair Maintainable Trade, open market rents and the type of services the pub offers (such as food or sports screenings) to calculate the rateable value. The same government agency assesses shops and other businesses solely on the physical area that the business occupies (less allowances for service areas such as toilets and stairwells) with no assessment of what level of trade a "competent operator" running whichever kind of business would generate. 

Another inconsistency is that holiday lettings accommodation have allowable deductions for repairs and maintenance, water rates, depreciation on fixtures and fittings and even the TV Licence! No such allowances are made for pubs (or for that matter shops). And I'll never believe a 'poor farmer' again when their land and most of their business related buildings are exempt from business rates.

Many small pubs (and hence small businesses) occupy roughly the same footprint as their retail neighbours and yet have rateable values significantly more than their counterparts. For instance in my last pub, where we occupied half a building (two of our four floors being the private accommodation on which we also paid Council Tax) the business rates, by dint of the multiplier, for our 'retail' business were 10 times more than that of the non-licensed retailer who occupied the other half of the premises.

Now add in the duties that are attached to the products that pubs sell (and enough of this has been written here and elsewhere) and any reasonable person would start to ask 'why are pubs so disproportionately taxed?' No doubt the answers will be that pubs use more resources such as the police and do more social harm as purveyors of the demon drink. But hang on aren't we already paying for that with duty? Won't some of us be paying for that with the Late Night Levy? 

Isn't it time that there was a complete overhaul of the business rates system? No, it's time to scrap them altogether and tax all businesses in the same way ... from each according to its means, i.e. from their profits. 

Think of the money that could be saved by reducing the Valuation Office's activities with respect to business rates, as an executive agency of HMRC it's officers could be assigned to other duties such as investigating tax avoidance and evasion ... but that's probably too simple a solution for 'Sir Humphrey' and his board even though HMRC's Vision Statement includes this statement:

"We will close the tax gap, our customers will feel that the tax system is simple for them and even-handed"

 (For advice on Business Rates read the article on the How To Run A Pub website)

Wednesday, 7 December 2011

Render unto Caesar ... but only as much as you should do ... & other stuff

September is the month when HMG takes the then current inflation rate and calculates how much the Universal Business Rate will be in the ensuing April.


This year the with inflation at over 5% HMG look set to rake in an extra £1.35 billion in commercial business rates. 


With all the pressures on pubs such as increased rents, increased supply costs, increased energy costs and the iniquitous beer duty escalator still in force we should all be looking very carefully at our business rates and where appropriate doing something about reducing them. To that end I have written a small piece on the How To Run A Pub website covering this very subject. You can find it by clicking here


Other recently added articles are on Customer Service and Staff Pensions


I hope you find all three articles useful.